When Faith Waits, the Flesh Schemes, And The Provision of God
Genesis 16:1-2, and 15-16
Now Sarai, Abram’s wife, had not borne him a child, but she had an Egyptian slave woman whose name was Hagar. So Sarai said to Abram, "See now, the Lord has prevented me from bearing children. Please have relations with my slave woman; perhaps I will obtain children through her." And Abram listened to the voice of Sarai...So Hagar bore a son to Abram; and Abram named his son, to whom Hagar gave birth, Ishmael. Abram was eighty-six years old when Hagar bore Ishmael to him.
The years have stretched on (ten years in Canaan by the time of this proposal). Sarai has borne no child. The delay of God's promises feels permanent. And Sarai correctly names the Lord’s sovereignty over the womb, yet she treats that sovereignty as a closed door rather than a call to wait. And now we see an ancient surrogacy tradition being extended into God's plans. A child born to the servant is counted as the mistress’s but Hagar assumes too much as a surrogate. Hagar is Egyptian, most likely acquired during the earlier detour into Egypt (Genesis 12). And so, we can see how the pagan influences can creep into and intoxicate God's people.
So here we are, the ancient surrogacy custom is then brought into the heart of the covenant promise. Now what began as a lapse under pressure becomes a permanent presence in the tent. The pagan practice has been baptized as a practical help for the promise.
Abram "listened to the voice of Sarai." The man who had just believed the Lord (Genesis 15:6) now heeds his wife’s counsel without any recorded inquiry of the God who had spoken. The flesh reaches for what is already in hand.
The servant is present.
The custom exists. Somebody somewhere is doing it.
The silent womb feels like prevention.
So they act.
Conception follows at once, but so does fracture. The household is torn between two women. Hagar, once given as a surrogate, soon "looked with contempt on her mistress" (16:4). Now the solution becomes the new problem.
What's the problem?
Human calculation has entered the story of the promise, and the household will now forever carry the weight of it. We will see that even today the children of God are experiencing the consequences of this human calculation.
The waiting of faith is replaced by the schemes of the flesh, when cultural patterns are baptized as helps for the promise, and when what was meant to solve the problem becomes the lasting wound in the household. And yet, God shows mercy to even those who He does not save. This is God's love. His love is mercy today. God shows grace today. And God hates sin and wickedness. So there is wrath alongside all that love. So in the meantime, all of us experience God's love, because God shows mercy and grace.
Hagar and Abraham's child is named Ishmael, Abraham was 86 years old. The name Ishmael ("God hears" ) is still given, and mercy is still shown. This is the son according to the flesh. And Hagar is forced out into the wilderness (probably headed back towards Egypt).
After Sarai deals harshly with her, Hagar flees into the wilderness. She is found by a spring of water on the way to Shur, the road that leads back toward Egypt. The Angel of the Lord finds her there. He asks two questions; "Where have you come from, and where are you going?" She answers only the first.
"I am fleeing from my mistress Sarai."
The angel tells her to return and submit to Sarai.
This is not an endorsement of the household’s scheme. It is an ordering of her life under the circumstances that already exist. Then He promises; "I will surely multiply your offspring so that they cannot be numbered for multitude." She will bear a son. His name is Ishmael, "because the Lord has listened to your affliction." He will be a wild donkey of a man, his hand against everyone and everyone’s hand against him, dwelling over against all his kinsmen.
The illegitimate child gets mercy. Mercy and realism stand together.
So an Egyptian servant girl, pregnant through human calculation, is driven out by her mistress who gave her in a scheme, is now seen by the living God. He does not overlook her affliction. He hears her. He speaks to her. He names her child before he is born. And He does not abandon her even while commanding her to return.
Ishmael is the son according to the flesh. The covenant heir will still come through Sarai. Yet the God who keeps His word to Abram is the same God who sees the servant in the wilderness. She calls the name of the Lord who spoke to her, "You are a God of seeing" (El Roi).
She says, "Truly here I have seen him who looks after me."
And there is a well; a well named Beer-lahai-roi, the well of the Living One who sees me.
What does this prove?
Our God is He who keeps His word to Abram and He is the same God who sees the servant in the wilderness. His seeing is not limited to the line of promise. His hearing reaches the afflicted. His mercy is not exhausted by His saving purposes.
Hagar returns. Ishmael is born in the household and named by Abram according to the word given in the wilderness. Not the heir God promised. He's illegitimate, the product of human sin. The true heir still waits. Grace has not erased the scheme, but neither has the scheme hidden the servant from the God who looks after her.
Later this distinction is made explicit in the New Testament (Galatians 4:22–31). And at the same time, the biblical text is clear that God made real promises concerning him. Later Ishmael grows up in the wilderness of Paran, becomes an expert with the bow, and his mother takes a wife for him from the land of Egypt (Genesis 21:20–21). Ishmael has twelve sons, listed as princes according to their tribes. These twelve become the tribal heads of the Ishmaelites. They settle in the region from Havilah to Shur, which is opposite Egypt in the direction of Assyria. Ishmael lives 137 years and dies.
God multiplies him into a large people organized into twelve tribes. They inhabit the broad desert and steppe regions east and south of Canaan. Their posture toward their kinsmen is one of living "over against" them. Nearby, related, yet distinct and often in tension. Ishmael’s line is not the channel of the covenant promise given to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. That line runs through Isaac.
The Ishmaelite's were traders. And interestingly, Ishmaelite traders were those who bought Joseph into slavery and carry him down to Egypt (Genesis 37). Fulfilling the prophecy God gave to Abram (Genesis 15:13). The scheme’s consequences remain. The God who sees still works. The true heir still comes. And even the people born of human calculation are drawn into the larger ordering by which the promise continues.
It's all the providential mercy of God at work. And even the clear and present danger to the promise today is linked to this paradox. In modern Muslim belief, Ishmael (Ismail) is a prophet, the ancestor of the Arab peoples, and specifically the forefather of Muhammad. Islamic sources hold that Abraham and Ishmael together built the Kaaba in Mecca, and that the Arab lineage; and therefore the prophetic line culminating in Muhammad, runs through Ishmael. It is a claim of Islamic tradition, not a claim made by the Bible. The Bible gives Ishmael a real place as Abraham’s son, a multiplied people of the wilderness regions, living in proximity and tension with the covenant line through Isaac. But the promise only follows Isaac's lineage.
The two claims are distinct.
Just as the two children given to Abram are distinct.
One is the son according to the flesh. The other is the son of the promise.
Now think about this. If Hagar had made it to Egypt and she became enveloped into that world again? She and her generations of children would have been wiped out by the later plagues God sends there. No Muslims. No Islam. No history of that ongoing conflict.
But God kept His promises to her. And set into motion everything we now know.
The provision of God.
Praise God, amen 🙏🏼