Genesis 12:17-20
But the Lord struck Pharaoh and his house with great plagues because of Sarai, Abram’s wife. Then Pharaoh called Abram and said, "What is this that you have done to me? Why did you not tell me that she was your wife? Why did you say, ‘She is my sister,’ so that I took her for myself as a wife? Now then, here is your wife, take her and go!" And Pharaoh commanded his men concerning him; and they escorted him away, with his wife and all that belonged to him.
From the beginning this whole deal has been very creepy. And Genesis 12:17–20 is the sharp, uncomfortable resolution of the crisis Abram created. And to make matters worse, Abram ends up wealthier than when he began. The sequence is plainly laid out; Abram anticipates the danger, instructs Sarai to present herself as his sister, she is taken into Pharaoh’s house, and only afterward does the Lord act. Genesis never spells out what happened between the taking and the plagues, but the narrative does not need to.
Pharaoh "took her".
Really?
Just what exactly does that mean?
The king "took her" (12:15) into the royal household; the plagues fall "because of Sarai" (12:17); and Pharaoh’s own words confirm that he had intended to keep her as a wife (12:19). This is like something right out of the Game of Thrones.
The text does not say the marriage was consummated; it does not say it was not. It simply records that she was taken into the royal household under the stated purpose of becoming a wife. In the world of the ancient Near East a king who "takes" a woman into his house "as a wife" is not placing her in protective custody. The arrangement is one of possession. And it seems to me that Pharaoh had already acted upon the arrangement when God's plagues interrupted him.
So, why does this story leave the reader with a bad taste in his mouth?
The text doesn't lean in that direction so why the distaste?
Up through Genesis 11 the narrative has not yet presented this particular sexual/marriage issue. Up till now we've not seen a husband’s deliberate strategy that places his wife inside another man’s household under the claim of marriage. What appears earlier is more limited. Genesis 2 establishes the one-flesh union and the language of leaving and cleaving. Genesis 3 records the fracture of that union and the shame of nakedness, but not the transfer of a wife. In Genesis 4 Lamech takes two wives and then boasts of violence; that is the first clear instance of polygamy, yet it is reported without any developed household intrigue or drama. Genesis 6 describes the sons of God taking wives from the daughters of men and the resulting violence, but the focus is on cosmic boundary-crossing and corruption. Genesis 9 contains the episode of Noah’s nakedness and Ham’s action; whatever the precise offense, it is not framed as a marital transaction between a husband, a wife, and a foreign ruler. Genesis 12 is therefore the first time the text shows a man who has received the covenant promise calculating that his wife’s beauty will endanger him, instructing her to conceal their marriage, and thereby arranging the conditions under which a king "takes" her into his house as a wife.
The text never gives Sarai a voice in this episode. She is spoken about, instructed, taken, and returned, but she never speaks. Abram's plan is framed entirely around his own safety. Her role is to perform the half-truth that protects him. And whatever interval passed between the taking and the plagues, she spent it inside that arrangement. The plan that kept Abram alive required her presence inside Pharaoh’s household, and the text never lets us hear what that required of her. But it's pretty clear even without the words.
It's notable that no pregnancy occurred as a result of this incident. But maybe the text can give us a clue into that. In Genesis 16, after years without a child Sarah proposes a plan.
"Behold now, the Lord has prevented me from bearing children. Go in to my servant; it may be that I shall obtain children by her" (16:2).
One could conclude from this that God did in fact prevent any child being produced from this game of thrones. And this is instructive in one sense, it shows the importance of Sarai's role in this covenant. The promise is repeatedly tied to Sarah herself (17:15–16; 18:10). Isaac is born to her in old age by God’s intervention, not through any earlier union. The two episodes in which she is taken into another man’s household both end with her restored and with no child attributed to those intervals. In the second case the text is explicit that God prevented consummation; in the first case it is silent, yet the outcome is the same; no pregnancy is recorded, and the promised son comes only later, from Abraham and Sarah.
I know what you're thinking.
"There's a second case?"
Yes, Abram likes this scheme of his and in chapter 20 we'll see him again employ this very same tactic that Pharaoh (not God) rebuked him for.
Why didn't God rebuke him?
I mean, Pharaoh took the heat and Abram came away richer and better positioned. Years later Abraham uses the same tactic with Abimelech. Again Sarah is taken, again a foreign king is warned by God, and again Abraham is confronted by the king rather than by a recorded divine rebuke addressed to him.
In both chapters the divine action is aimed at the kings and at the protection of Sarah. No judgement for Abraham. The confrontations that do occur come from Pharaoh and from Abimelech. They are the ones who ask the accusing questions and demand an accounting. It seems that God lets these games play out without condemning them. In fact, Abraham's own words when pressed on these things is excuses rooted in fear, not confessions met by a divine word of correction.
What the chapters show, then, is selective intervention. God acts decisively on the side of the promise and on the side of Sarah’s restoration. He does not, in these passages, act as the one who cross-examines Abraham or who declares the deception as disqualifying.
The kings perform their role.
The narrative records the answers and moves on.
God's Word neither endorses the tactic nor supplies the condemnation that would close the moral question. But in the end, Abram (and Sarai by default) gets hugely wealthy and well positioned as a result. The games are allowed to run their course under the limitation that Sarah must be returned and the promised son must still come from her.
This divine protection is active and repeated throughout the generations.
What does that say about God and the game of thrones?
What the biblical text selectivity says is something precise about the God of these chapters. He is more concerned with the integrity of His own word than with the immediate moral consistency of the man through whom the word is advancing. Abraham can calculate, conceal, and repeat the calculation; and the promise does not fail. Foreign kings can act on the information they are given; and they are divinely stopped short of undoing the promise.
The seed is guarded even when the bearer of the promise is the one who placed it at risk. The narrative thereby presents a God who will let the human game continue, and even let the covenant bearer profit from it, provided the one thing He has bound Himself to (the offspring through Sarah) remains intact. The games are permitted to run their course up to the boundary God has fixed. Beyond that boundary He intervenes, every time.
God is in control.
Amen 🙏🏼